| Platinum | Addictive Hobbies & Games |
| Gold | The 3D Shoppe |
| Silver | Dailey Hobbies |
| Silver | Little Shoppe Treasures |
| Bronze | Kat's Craft Corner |
| Top Pick | Brew Wizards Board Game Café |
| Top Pick | Comic Alley Toys |
| Top Pick | Kendal Heights Decor & Woodworking |
| Top Pick | The Gamer's Table |
| Top Pick | We Made It |