| Platinum | Square Boy Pizza Subs & Wings |
| Gold | La Pizza & Pasta |
| Silver | JR's Handmade Sourdough Pizza |
| Bronze | Tuscan Wolf Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Little Caesars Pizza |
| Top Pick | Lowlands Fire Foods |
| Top Pick | Papas Pizzaland |
| Top Pick | Pizzamunno |
| Top Pick | Portobello Road |
| Top Pick | Red Swan Pizza |