| Platinum | Avanti Trattoria |
| Gold | Scaddabush Italian Kitchen & Bar |
| Silver | Tuscan Wolf Pizzeria |
| Bronze | Bella Notte Ristorante |
| Top Pick | Chicago Deli Express |
| Top Pick | Ciao Amici |
| Top Pick | Hot Rocks Creative Diner |
| Top Pick | La Pizza & Pasta |
| Top Pick | Papas Pizzaland |
| Top Pick | Pizza Nova |